Both of my daughters are good athletes and both have been active at the school and the community level. I encourage them to pursue both athletics and the arts, in addition to their core academic studies, as part of a well rounded education that will serve them well in the years ahead. My involvement, growing up, with athletics was, however, more limited. I played softball and was for a number of years, part of a bowling league. I was a better bowler than softball pitcher but there was no chance in either case that my number or shirt would be retired.
I also considered learning how to be an umpire or a referee but ultimately didn’t pursue it. I did realize at an early age the key role played by individuals who serve in these important capacities. A few weeks ago my younger daughter came home, after one of her community games, and talked at length about the referees for game she had just played. She indicated that the kids on her team, as well as the coach, were upset at how biased the referees were in officiating at the game. Rules violations made by the other team were ignored while every violation and even some non-violations were singled out for her team. I have also witnessed, at other games, what I have thought to be some bias in officiating (not at the college level) but also realize that my knowledge of the rules and at times my less than total focus on the game may cloud my objectivity. I also understand that the more informal the league and the younger the kids playing (often with referees that are just a few years older) the more likelihood that there will be errors.
Errors happen but if there is biased officiating, it needs to be reported and corrected. We all know that cheating is a major problem that permeates many schools and levels of education. We all do everything we can to limit academic dishonesty so that the work we judge is the student’s work and not the result of someone else’s efforts. Biased officiating tells kids that results may not be based on effort or skill but rather on manipulation and distortion. Biased officiating is clearly cheating with the rules of the game differently and selectively applied. Neutrality and even-handedness need to be the baseline for referees and umpires.
I am a strong advocate for not looking the other way when there is academic dishonesty in any form. The message and the response need to make it clear that cheating is not acceptable and the penalty must reflect the seriousness of the academic dishonesty. Refereeing needs to be kept at the highest standards possible even if that requires more training. There is an important life lesson in losing a game if you have been outplayed by your opponent. But losing because the playing field wasn’t level is a life lesson that causes our kids to question the fairness of the system and also gets them to question whether their effort is worth it when the result is based on other factors. I know this is also an important life lesson, but for me, especially when it comes to our kids, I would like us all to demonstrate that such problems and failures of the system are relatively few and far between.
Showing posts with label Cheating. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cheating. Show all posts
Monday, November 18, 2013
Monday, September 24, 2012
Cheating
The cheating scandal at Harvard which could involve as many as 125 students in a single class has gotten extensive publicity. And the impression given is that this is an unusual event. For example, as quoted in the New York Times, Harvard’s dean of undergraduate education noted that this cheating incident at Harvard “is unprecedented in its scope and magnitude.” This may be correct, given that it involves almost half of the class, but cheating and academic dishonesty are not unusual events and the “scope and magnitude” of what happens nationwide is certainly disturbing.
Mr. Harris, in the same New York Times article notes that “the enabling role of technology is a big part of the picture.” He continues by stating “It’s the ease of sharing. With that has come, I believe a certain cavalier attitude.” True enough but there are two other factors that I believe are an important part of this equation. First, and this was not the case at Harvard, faculty are often reluctant to bring cheating to the attention of their administration preferring instead to administer their own justice for incidents of academic dishonesty. This justice varies widely for the same infraction from faculty member to faculty member. I understand the faculty mentality and respect it, and I also understand the reluctance to follow a cookie cutter approach in determining penalties or grades. But what is lost in this approach is that repeat incidents of cheating need a stronger response but if an incident is not reported to administration, there is no way to ramp up the penalty for the next incident. As a faculty member, I might be lenient on a first infraction on the part of an undergraduate. I certainly wouldn’t be lenient regarding any infraction by a graduate student and I wouldn’t be lenient toward any repeat offense. We need to coordinate our efforts regarding academic dishonesty. Cheating is a nationwide problem. It will not disappear quickly and only a response that is both resolute and yet understanding of faculty prerogatives can work to moderate the problem.
Cheating doesn’t just start in college. It starts much earlier and is equally pervasive in much of middle and high school education. It actually starts earlier in elementary school and unfortunately parents may be playing an enabling role in the cheating that is going on. We all recognize that parents play a critical role in the education of their children and that teachers together with parents are key factors in the success of children. But where should parents draw the line in helping their kids. My wife and I both read to and listened to the reading of both of our kids when they were very young. I hope we helped them read earlier and more fluently. But we have never felt that their homework was our homework and we never hovered over them until their assignments were perfection. And we never have felt that their grades are our grades and that we had to help them in any way possible to get the highest grade possible.
Mr. Harris, in the same New York Times article notes that “the enabling role of technology is a big part of the picture.” He continues by stating “It’s the ease of sharing. With that has come, I believe a certain cavalier attitude.” True enough but there are two other factors that I believe are an important part of this equation. First, and this was not the case at Harvard, faculty are often reluctant to bring cheating to the attention of their administration preferring instead to administer their own justice for incidents of academic dishonesty. This justice varies widely for the same infraction from faculty member to faculty member. I understand the faculty mentality and respect it, and I also understand the reluctance to follow a cookie cutter approach in determining penalties or grades. But what is lost in this approach is that repeat incidents of cheating need a stronger response but if an incident is not reported to administration, there is no way to ramp up the penalty for the next incident. As a faculty member, I might be lenient on a first infraction on the part of an undergraduate. I certainly wouldn’t be lenient regarding any infraction by a graduate student and I wouldn’t be lenient toward any repeat offense. We need to coordinate our efforts regarding academic dishonesty. Cheating is a nationwide problem. It will not disappear quickly and only a response that is both resolute and yet understanding of faculty prerogatives can work to moderate the problem.
Cheating doesn’t just start in college. It starts much earlier and is equally pervasive in much of middle and high school education. It actually starts earlier in elementary school and unfortunately parents may be playing an enabling role in the cheating that is going on. We all recognize that parents play a critical role in the education of their children and that teachers together with parents are key factors in the success of children. But where should parents draw the line in helping their kids. My wife and I both read to and listened to the reading of both of our kids when they were very young. I hope we helped them read earlier and more fluently. But we have never felt that their homework was our homework and we never hovered over them until their assignments were perfection. And we never have felt that their grades are our grades and that we had to help them in any way possible to get the highest grade possible.
Homework is to be the results of the students’ efforts, not the results of the students’ efforts plus substantial help from your parents or others. Take home exams are the results of the students’ efforts not the result of the students’ efforts plus the help of others. Grades are based on the work done by the student, not (under usual circumstances) by a group. At every grade we need to reinforce the importance of the students’ efforts and at every grade we need to reinforce the penalty that will be paid if that effort turns out to be the result of someone else’s intervention. And the penalties need to be much harsher for any repeat offense.
Labels:
Cheating,
collaboration,
harvard,
homework,
integrity,
sharing,
technology
Monday, January 9, 2012
The SAT Scandal
I just finished listening to the Sam Eshagoff interview on
60 Minutes. Before I comment on the
interview, I would like to commend 60 Minutes for decades of worthwhile news
and human interest coverage. 60 Minutes
remains a leading example of TV at its best.
I am not as positive about either Sam Eshaghoff or ETS. I’m not sure that Sam has learned his lesson
or that he understands the seriousness of what he did. He does understand he got caught and that
seems to have caused some regret. But
anyone who believes that he “saved the lives” of students with awful records by
taking the SATs for those students so they could get into schools that were
otherwise unachievable, but doesn’t understand that he likely adversely
impacted the lives of students who presented honest records but were not accepted
because of space taken up by cheaters, doesn’t comprehend the seriousness of
his actions. Students need to be judged
on their work; an awful record should not be neutralized or turned into a
positive because the student and/or his or her family could pay for what the Nassau
County Attorney General rightly calls “an academic hired gun.” Sam may call his actions saving a life, I
call it criminal fraud. That Eshagoff doesn’t get jail time makes sense to me
but that his sentence is tutoring economically disadvantaged students on test
taking, at what seems to be at his convenience, is too lenient given the fraud
involved and the righteous attitude of saving lives presented during the TV interview.
Does he realize how wrong and how serious his actions were?
The attitude expressed by ETS on 60 Minutes also needs
work. To be told we should not “overreact”
to a system that lacked even minimal security is disconcerting. I would agree that the vast majority of test
takers are honest and therefore that the vast majority of test scores are
accurate assessments of test taking capability.
But there clearly is and has been cheating. That there hasn’t been more cheating does not seem to be due to the efforts of ETS; rather
it is a reflection of most people being honest.
Cheating needs to be dealt with firmly on all levels. The ETS test taking procedures are being
tightened up and that is a positive sign.
But the policy where no action is taken by ETS after the fact against a
known cheater leaves much to be desired in my mind. Basically it says since we didn’t catch you
in a timely manner, you get a free pass and are able to enjoy the fruits of
your ill gotten gains. It may take
substantial time to catch up with some criminals, including those guilty of
white collar crimes. But does it really make sense to say that since we didn’t
catch you at the time you took the test, you are free of all repercussions? I
don’t think so.
I hope the investigations continue and that as many as
possible of the individuals who wrongfully took exams for others are caught and
held accountable. And I hope that ETS is
able to tighten procedures and restore the confidence we had in them. As
educators we work hard to ensure that academic honesty is maximized. Part of our mission is to make clear to our
students the importance of honesty and its key role in our value system. But part of our responsibility is also
exposing cheating when it takes place and making sure there is
accountability. And I think we all would
agree that we can and should do more on both counts.
Labels:
60 Minutes,
Cheating,
integrity,
Sam Eshaghoff,
SAT,
scandal
Monday, December 5, 2011
Test Takers
I had a terrific experience as a doctoral student. The
courses, the faculty, the other students all made for a wonderful educational
journey. I was certain economics was the right field for me before I began and
I was even more certain by the time I graduated. Within this wonderful experience, one moment
still stands out, not because it directly involved economics, not because it
represented an intellectual breakthrough, but rather because I learned an
important life lesson.
That moment was when I took my statistics qualifying
examination. That day approximately a
dozen students came to take the exam.
The faculty proctor handed out the exam and we all began. Now the statistics qualifying exam had a
reputation for being rigorous but also had a reputation as an exam where
typically 5 people passed. If there were
a small number of test takers or a larger number, the results always seemed to
be the same—five students passed. About
thirty minutes into a two hour exam, the proctor decided to leave the room
while we all continued working on our examinations. Shortly thereafter one thing changed. Even though this was not an open book
examination, one of the test takers took out the textbook plus a notebook, and
began working on the answers with the added support in clear view. What did I
do and what did the rest of the class do?
Each of us just kept working on the examination and following the rules.
About an hour later, the proctor returned for the last 30
minutes of the examination period.
Within a few minutes most of us handed in our exams and left the room. I thought I did well on the exam but nevertheless,
was a little apprehensive. I didn’t say
anything to the proctor as I was leaving about the person cheating, and to my
knowledge neither did anyone else. A day
or two later, I found out that one of my classmates reported the student who
cheated. His exam was disallowed and I
was told he was suspended from the program.
A penalty that was certainly deserved.
When the results of the exam became known about two weeks
later, I was relieved to learn that I had passed. Five students passed this qualifying exam,
and going from highest to lowest passing grade, I was number 5. If the cheater hadn’t been turned in, I
assume I would not have passed.
I have been thinking about the Long Island students who paid
other students to take the SATs for them.
For a few thousand dollars, they were on the fast track to a much more
impressive SAT score and the resulting benefits in terms of gaining admission
or being awarded a scholarship. But very
often, just as was the case in my statistics qualifying examination, someone
cheating their way to admission or a scholarship likely precluded the person
deserving the recognition from receiving it. In all the publicity regarding the exam takers
and those who paid for someone to take the exam, the real potential victims
have not been identified. They are the individuals who did everything right,
but nevertheless would have been shortchanged out of the
positive results of their efforts. I
know it can happen. It almost happened
to me.
I often think that we are not as stringent as we should be
in our monitoring and enforcement of academic honesty and I also think that we
are often too lenient in the penalties we impose for violations of academic
honesty. If we are to be fair to the
individuals who do everything the way it should be done, we (faculty, students,
and administrators) need to do more to eliminate cheating. If we turn the other
cheek to cheating, we are hurting ourselves and cheating the system that we are
part of.
Monday, October 10, 2011
Cheating
Six students from a top Long Island high school each hired
the same recent high school graduate to take the SATs for them so that they
could submit a higher test score than they would receive on their own as part
of their college admissions profile. I
am pleased they were caught but I’m certain that these students are not the
only students who have substituted other individuals in their place to take
important admissions and other examinations.
What should happen to these high school students? The punishment should be severe (though I
wouldn’t advocate jail time). How
severe? If they are guilty as charged, I
would recommend they should be barred from submitting a SAT test score or a
high school transcript for at least a year and during that time they should
provide extensive mandatory community service. A course on ethics should also
be required. The test taker should also
face at least as severe a punishment.
And if there were any parents that aided and abetted this effort, their
punishment should be much more severe. Furthermore, it appears that we need to
substantially improve test security so that every possible safeguard is in
place to prevent anyone else from taking the place of the student who is
supposed to be the test taker.
Academic honesty is a problem in many high schools and in
many colleges and universities. At
times, especially since we are dealing with young adults, the plagiarism is unintentional. At other times, the cheating is both
intentional and on-going. Many teachers
and professors will react forcefully to cheating as it happens but at the same
time intentionally moderate or eliminate long term consequences. Often cheating is not reported so as not to
tarnish the student’s record and often the punishment is determined based on
this cheating being a once in a lifetime occurrence, not a pattern. Once in a lifetime suggest that a moderate
response is appropriate; a pattern suggests there needs to be an escalating response. How do we know what response is appropriate
if the tracking system throughout much of a student’s education is rife with
omissions? We really need to do better
so that the message is more clearly and emphatically that academic dishonesty
doesn’t pay.
Students are very aware of who cheats and students can help
foster an environment where academic honesty is valued but at the same time, I
don’t think we should count on students alone to play a lead role in moderating
the cheating of other students.
What can we do? Every
incident of cheating—unless it is clearly not intentional—should be
reported. The penalty for an individual
offense should be determined by the faculty member but there needs to be an
additional penalty triggered by repeat offenses. Every student can make a mistake and learn
from his/her mistakes. But more than one
occurrence should be accompanied by a zero tolerance response that should, if
it continues, result in suspension and, if justified, dismissal.
The penalty should also escalate as students advance in
their education. We should all be more
tolerant of a high school student or a first year college student making a
mistake and much less tolerant of an advanced undergraduate or graduate student
having an ethical lapse. And in certain
fields such as law and medicine, the penalty for academic dishonesty, if proven, should be immediate dismissal.
All of us comment with dismay on the widespread culture
where academic dishonesty is more or less prevalent. But to change the environment we need to do
more than comment and more than deal with individual occurrences. We need as a community to work together, to report
and to track academic dishonesty as it happens.
If we are determined to reduce academic dishonesty, our actions can help
make it happen.
Monday, September 14, 2009
The Academic Dishonesty Virus
I’m an economist and my typical reading pattern, especially on a weekend when I tend to have more time, is to gravitate first to the major economic news. But my reading patterns as of this past summer have changed dramatically: I now look first for news on H1N1. As is true for almost all of us, there is a measure of self interest in my starting with flu-related articles. But what motivates me most to look for H1N1 news is the potential impact on the University. We know from the CDC as well as from state guidelines that the expectation is in most cases for most individuals, that this flu will last 2-4 days and that most people will recover without seeing a doctor. We have been asked and we will make allowances for students who may miss up to 5 class days with H1N1. We will make allowances for students who miss regularly scheduled exams (even final exams). And we will prepare for the contingency that a number of faculty will contract this virus and will not be able to come to class for a few days. We will do all of this while attempting to make certain the standards are not compromised.
Labels:
Absence,
Academic Honesty,
Cheating,
Dishonesty,
Flu,
H1N1
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)