Showing posts with label tuition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tuition. Show all posts

Monday, April 23, 2012

Differential Tuition


I’m was not at all surprised when Santa Monica College abandoned their  proposed two-tier fee schedule.  Charging more for more popular courses alienates both students as well as faculty.  And if one three credit course earns as much credit toward graduation as another three credit course, how can there be a differential pricing mechanism? 

But let’s go back a step to the actual cost of a course.  Costs vary widely.  A course can be taught by a full time faculty member or by an adjunct faculty member with very different cost ramifications; or by a senior faculty member or a junior faculty member, once again with very different cost ramifications.  A course can be taught as a seminar and the same course can often be taught in a large lecture section, once again with very different cost considerations, even if the actual faculty cost for the seminar and the lecture were identical.  Most courses are taught in standard classrooms but many are also taught in labs of varying sophistication.  Lab or studio courses tend to have smaller enrollment limits (based on available lab stations) than regular classrooms.  And for both equipment reasons and seating availability, these courses tend to have a higher cost base.  But the cost consequences of courses often extend outside of the classroom.  Library and technology needs vary widely and can significantly increase the cost base.  And these differences can even take place in the same department and discipline, and also remember that different disciplines often have market related cost differences.  There are so many cost differences inherent in higher education, that it would be impossible to build them into the cost structure.  We are not a department store, supermarket or restaurant where every discrete item has its own cost.  What we are selling is the opportunity for students to earn credits, and the credits each have identical value.

Differential pricing is not a new concept.  There are different schools and programs within the same university that charge different tuition rates.  Typically these differences are on the graduate level, where the programs are self-contained and do not cross over to other schools or programs.  When differences are built into the undergraduate level, the mechanism most used is a (lab or technology or equipment) fee.  And there are differential scholarships that are awarded, once again especially on the graduate level where the programs are self contained.  Graduate programs where there is tremendous demand tend to award smaller scholarships than those programs striving to assure a critical mass of students. 

What should a hard pressed institution do when it needs to generate additional revenue?  Not an easy question.  Charging more for popular courses is not the right strategy.  Courses are often “popular” because they are required for graduation.  There is no basis for charging more for these courses.  Of course at the extreme, you could charge so much more for these courses that students would substitute into much less popular courses (in areas where staffing is nevertheless abundant) that would meet the same graduation requirements.   Students might hate the course but they would appreciate the lower cost.  Not a strategy I would ever be likely to embrace.  Charging a fee, where there are no obvious extra costs is also not a good strategy.  How could you charge a fee in a room where there are just seats and a white board, or even seats and a smart board?  In addition, reducing scholarships, especially when much of this money goes to meet need, is also not a desired strategy.  And containing all costs is also not a workable solution either for the institution or the individuals working at the institution.  Larger class sizes mask the issue but don’t ultimately solve the problem in most cases.  Lastly, fundraising, even though it is extremely important, is likely to have an impact only at the margin.

What are we left with?  Tuition increases may be the only alternative.  Inflation does exist, costs do increase and as unpopular as such increases may be, they may also be the response that makes the most sense.

Monday, March 29, 2010

Undercover Economics

Given the severity of our current recession, everyone I know has either been touched directly by this economic malaise or knows someone who has been adversely impacted – jobs lost or not found, salaries reduced or not increased, houses lost or not purchased, health insurance foregone, vacations foregone and the list goes on and on.  People are clearly hurting.  But the impact of this and any recession is on more than people; colleges and universities are good examples of institutions adversely impacted. The adverse impact can happen in many ways and take many forms; some are almost invisible with a price to be paid only over a long term time period.

We know that support from governments for public higher education has declined in many parts of the country.  As support has declined, tuition has increased and often there have been major increases in fees as well. In community colleges where the cost of education is lower (both for the supplier and the consumer) there have been some dramatic increases in enrollment.  In four year and graduate public institutions, enrollments are more likely capped and in some areas reduced.  Often at the same time that tuition is rapidly increasing, so is the use of adjuncts and the average class size. Faculty travel and sabbaticals in support of research are often also adversely impacted.

Private higher education faces many of the same challenges.  The difference between public higher education tuition (where there are varying degrees of government support) and private higher education tuition (where such support is much more limited and most likely tied to financial need) prompts some families, especially during economic uncertainty, to favor the lower priced alternative (even if they clearly recognize the benefits of private higher education).  Or the uncertainty could lead to more commuter students rather than residential students. Private higher education’s response, almost across the board is to increase need and or merit based financial aid, which requires almost across the board tuition increases as the funding source.  And here too, adjunct usage is increasing as is average class size.

The economic consequences of these actions are visible to either a greater or lesser degree to the student and his or her family.  Tuition increases are clear to everyone; increased class size is clear only if you have a basis for comparison; and increased use of adjuncts is much less visible.  But there are other effects which are even more undercover.  First of all, what is taking place is a fundamental shift in the allocation of resources away from the classroom.  Because funding has declined or because more dollars need to be allocated to financial aid, the dollars spent on education have been constrained. There is no alternative but unless too many resources were originally allocated to direct classroom education something has been lost. And it remains to be seen whether the allocation will shift back again to the classroom experience either in the short term or in the longer term.  For faculty, and faculty clearly are the heart of the education we provide, the lack of job opportunities for new faculty, the increased economic uncertainly for continuing faculty, larger classes and the reduced level of support for research can result in a morale problem that could extend past the current recession.  All at the same time as we look to faculty to play an increased role in retention.

Overall, as we move forward, we need to objectively look at what we have enhanced and what we have compromised.  And where compromises have been made, we must look for opportunities to restore what has been lost.

Monday, February 22, 2010

A Tuition Rate Only an Economist Could Love

A major story in last Tuesday’s Inside Higher Education was that Middlebury College “will plan its budgets each year by capping its ‘comprehensive fee’ – the equivalent of tuition, room and board at other private colleges—at an upward limit of 1 percentage point above the Consumer Price Index.”  Certainly this move makes good sense in terms of positive publicity for Middlebury and it also provides a valuable fiscal restraint framework to operate under.  But would I, as an economist, advocate this framework and does it make sense for higher education in general?