Showing posts with label policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label policy. Show all posts

Monday, February 6, 2012

Important Role of Government

I am today philosophically close to where I was when I was in graduate school. I am a middle of the road economist. I recognize the importance of government fiscal and monetary policy and yet government needs to make sure it doesn’t micromanage where it isn’t necessary, and government needs to make sure that the laws are constructed in the fairest way possible. I’m not sure at this moment that government—all levels of government—are doing all they can do to be fair and to not micromanage. For example, when a major presidential candidate can earn over $20 million dollars per year and not pay more than a 15% tax rate, I question the fairness of the system. I don’t fault Mitt Romney—there is no reason that he should pay more than is required. Nor should he be ashamed either of his earning power and his level of taxation. He is an American success story. I do, however, fault our federal government for creating a tax structure where the wealthiest Americans are so clearly paying a lesser percentage than millions of Americans whose earnings are a fraction of Governor Romney’s earnings. I would never suggest we impose an onerous tax rate for individuals in this bracket and perhaps we should all pay the same percentage, but no one should believe that the system that presently exists meets the fairness test. I’ve written before about defined benefit pension plans. There is no question that they are very beneficial for the recipients but there is also no question that substituting certainty for risk on the part of the pension recipients is made possible at the expense of tax payers. These are the same tax payers who, for the most part, save what they can for retirement without the ability to shelter these monies from the winds of economic uncertainty. What a nice system it is when you win if the stock market rises and you can’t lose if the stock market falls. I would never diminish the defined benefit pension plans for those who already have them. But can we really justify their continuation in the same form going forward? And to prop up these pensions, what are we now not able to do which meet important needs. Are we cutting back, for example, on our support for public K-12 education? Bad decision and bad news for the competitive future of our country. The few times in my life that I have seen momentary price controls, the end results have been serious market disruptions. In a market economy, it doesn’t really work to bypass the market. And now there is mention of government efforts to limit tuition increases. The market already is an effective brake on excessive tuition increases. If the value equation isn’t there for a particular college or university, there are multiple other universities—private as well as public, senior as well as community – to chose from. A dynamic institution striving to make greater use of full-time faculty, or greater merit-based or need-based scholarships, or smaller class size, or new majors in more costly areas, may need a larger than average tuition rate increase. Should institutions making initiatives like this be dissuaded from doing so or penalized for doing so? It makes no sense. And I do understand the high cost of education and the strains that it puts on many families. Competition from lower priced alternatives including on-line degree programs or for profit colleges and universities are better alternatives than price controls. Here is my dilemma and the dilemma for so many of us. Government is a lifeline we all need but when government undermines a level playing field, we are all hurt.

Monday, October 17, 2011

Demand and Supply


The 2010 Georgetown University Center for Education and the Workforce study of “Projections of Jobs and Education Requirements Through 2018” concluded that “by 2018 we will need 22 million new college degrees- but will fall short of that number by at least 3 million postsecondary degrees, Associate or better.”  Furthermore, the report states “we will need at least 4.7 million new workers with postsecondary certificates. “ The report comes to two other conclusions, all conclusions that will not surprise the higher education community.  First, the report notes that “between 1973 and 2008, the share of jobs in the U.S. economy which required postsecondary education increased from 28 percent to 59 percent.  And second that “as the economy evolved, postsecondary education gradually became the threshold requirement for access to middle class status and earnings.”

But there is a fundamental disconnect between the increasing need for higher education credentials and the support by government of students pursuing this education.  Be it on the graduate level or on the undergraduate level, financial support for students as well as for institutions is declining.  Consequently in a lackluster economy, with many families straining to afford the education for their children, the diminished support makes it more difficult to pursue added education and less likely that this investment will be made.

Education is first and foremost an investment, an investment in the personal growth of the individual undertaking the education as well as an investment in the economy.  Our economy needs workers with sophisticated skills sets to do the increasingly more complex jobs that are available in fields such as the sciences, healthcare, business and education.  In a global economy and in a highly technological time, there are no substitutes for such workers.  As one example, if we look at health care where we are striving, rightly so, to provide a health care safety net for all our citizens, how will we be able to vastly increase the services needed by this broader base of our population without expanding the supply of educated workers?  Laws can provide accessibility but without the necessary supply, the results will not be there.

Especially in those areas that are vital to our economic growth and to the well being of our population, there needs to be a well thought out policy that provides more, not less, resources for higher education.  We should highlight the areas with the greatest need for skilled workers, and I think we already know this information for at least the next decade.   Next, we should publicize where those areas are and what the required educational attainment is for a person to succeed in those fields.  This information needs to be conveyed to students in middle and high schools and also to their families so that it can be fully considered as part of the decision making process in regard to postsecondary education. And then to further make sure the supply of skilled workers is commensurate with our needs, we need to develop specific economic incentives.  These incentives should be targeted just to increase workers in areas of need; in a time of scarce resources we need to carefully and precisely allocate those resources.  Yes, this will cost money; yes, we will need to increase our support of postsecondary education; and yes, this will impact the decision making process of these students/future workers.  But we have no choice.  To allow a fundamental disequilibrium to exist between needed skills and the number of workers with those skills is to relegate our economy to clearly falling short of its potential.  And the more we fall short of our potential, the more we face an economy unable to do all we all need done.