Showing posts with label higher education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label higher education. Show all posts

Monday, November 4, 2013

Change

Our new students have been on campus for about 6 weeks but we are already entering prime season in recruiting new students.  I already have had the pleasure of talking to the first fall open house group of the season and potential students and their families were very clearly focused on the decision they likely would be making in the next 6 months.  In thinking about my talk to these students and their loved ones, I focused on what I have heard from parents and new/potential students last year as well as what I have heard from talking with students and parents in the school district where I live. 

There seems to be, up to the last few weeks when the ill conceived effort to defund Obamacare threatened to undermine the slowly progressing economic recovery, a greater sense of optimism permeating our country.  Hopefully, that sense of optimism will reappear in the weeks ahead.  Optimism works to shift some attention from the sticker price of higher education to the value inherent in the education.  In a weak economy, price often trumps all; when the economy improves, class size, personal attention, and support services all take on greater prominence.  Scholarships, however, remain an important part of the currency of higher education; parents clearly feel they have been more successful, along with the son or daughter, when a scholarship is part of the attraction.

Even with the economy improving, students and their families seem to be maintaining their focus on the job or graduate school opportunity at the end of the baccalaureate degree studies.  Thankfully our increased attention to outcomes assessment provides us with reliable information on what recent graduates are doing and that information is very reassuring.  Students and their parents also seem to be maintaining their interest in and enthusiasm for an internship along the way. I strongly agree that an internship can provide that important bridge between school and a career and provide the student with added sophistication that increases the chances for success.  Dual degree programs also seem to be more and more attractive to potential students.  The opportunity to earn both a bachelor’s degree and a master’s degree in an overall shorter period of time enhances the value proposition.  Think about it, even five years ago and certainly a decade ago, there was much less concern about the job at the end of the degree, much less emphasis on internships, and much less emphasis on dual degrees.  I believe the new priorities have strengthened higher education but there certainly has been a price to be paid.

The price has been the declining appreciation for the importance of a well rounded liberal arts education as the foundation for higher education.  A dual major, a minor along with a major, more time for internships, a chance at a dual degree, all are often made possible by a reduction on the number of foundational liberal arts courses that are the critical source of the common body of knowledge that higher education should provide.  The appreciation for the liberal arts is often overshadowed now by the desire to have more professional experiences, certifications and credentials.  Graduates are often expected to be more specialists and less generalists, more sophisticated in the imediate needs of the chosen profession but less able to understand world issues and challenges.

We all work hard to provide incoming students and their families with the quality education they want in their chosen field.  We change with the changing times and here there is no choice.  But along with the changes, there also has to be an ongoing commitment to the liberal arts.  Higher education should never be confused with a trade school education.


Monday, October 21, 2013

Car Focus

It is the time of year when the new automobile models are being introduced and as usual I find myself looking to read everything I can about the new models.  I have been fascinated by cars since I was a young kid, and only later on did I realize how important the automobile industry was to the American economy.  Now I am not a believer that whatever is good for GM (or Ford of Chrysler) is good for the United States, but I do believe that the American car industry doing well is inextricably interwoven with the American economy doing well.

For many years, the greatest excitement about the new models being introduced was reserved for foreign cars, for the most part those cars imported either from Germany or Japan. And the reality was that I was part of the foreign car bandwagon.  American cars didn’t excite me and more importantly, I just didn’t have a sense that they were as durable or well designed as the German or Japanese cars. Now American cars are at the top of the list in almost every category.  The new Corvette, the new Impala, the new Cadillac CTS, the new Jeep Cherokee, the new Ford Fusion are all the best of breed; tested continuously and praised for all they represent and for all the value they provide.  And because American cars are so good at doing what they should do, it is no longer unusual to see American cars well represented in important foreign cities.  Beijing and Buick is the best example.

In many ways, the higher education industry is in a similar position.  American higher education is respected at home and around the globe. The impact of higher education on the economy – taking into consideration all levels of public and private education– is huge, and here too, the American economy doing well is dependent on higher education continuing to do well.  We need to be relevant, we need to be reasonable, and we need to be a good investment in the future.  Foreign competition continues to grow but in almost every area, our education is still the most sought after.

At times, for the automobile industry, economic incentives have been key to the public’s purchase of automobiles.  No money down, very low interest rates, low leasing rates, and discounts off the sticker price have all made a difference.  Discount rates are key to higher education purchases as well.  Either scholarships or well below cost public tuition provide the same, price cutting, economic incentives.  As the economy improved and as cars improved, the automobile industry was able to reduce the reliance on price incentives.  In higher education, we are still struggling with how to come to grips with price incentives.  And what makes it especially difficult is that public institutions may have exactly the same cost structure but because there is a subsidy from the state where the public institution is located, public institutions do their discounting up front and visible for all to see.  Imagine higher education, if Ford were a public company with a permanent subsidy for all Ford purchasers.  What would GM and Chrysler do?

I know many of us – especially in the private section– are looking for ways to reduce the increasing reliance in higher education on discounting to attract students.  Since it is no longer unusual for a private institution to approach 50% in the first year discount rate, the pace of discount rate increases by definition will slow down.  But unfortunately, I don’t see a workable solution for phasing out what so many of us have become dependent on.


Monday, March 5, 2012

Customer Service

I was reminded a few weeks ago, in response to a situation I will outline in the next paragraph, of how important customer service is throughout education and especially at the very competitive higher education level. And by customer service, I am not suggesting a weakening of standards; rather, I am just suggesting that we, especially in private higher education, do all that is necessary to minimize administrative hassles and in that way help our students succeed. A colleague at another very good private institution was telling me about a student, who was completing his third degree at this institution. He needed just one more course to earn his second graduate degree and had a potential excellent job opportunity (in an area where there is a tough job market) that was contingent on competing the degree before the end of January. The school involved didn’t have this course scheduled in the winter session, didn’t offer this course in January, and the administrators contacted were not responsive to the student even given the compelling nature of the student’s request—not to do any less work, but rather just complete the degree within this session so as to take advantage of an important opportunity. The administrators contacted felt that because this course had never before been offered during a winter session, it should not be offered now and besides, since this was an intensive course, there was no way the student could do the work involved. The story has a happy ending. More senior level administrators, responding to an appeal from the student, intervened and asked that the course be given as a tutorial (or independent study) type course. The student was assigned everything that a student taking the course in a regular semester was expected to do, and he did it all well and in the shortened time frame available. The faculty member upheld standards and worked with a highly motivated student and the rest was history. The administrator telling me this story concluded by stating how much he hoped the possible job opportunity would work out for the student (now a three-time alum). I do too, but even if it doesn’t, I expect that this alum will be a very loyal and supportive graduate of an institution that helped when help was needed at a key time in his life/career. The person who preceded me as Provost often said when looking for a model of good customer service, we should emulate a Bloomingdale’s rather than a Korvette’s or an Alexander’s. Don’t know or remember those two chains which were very prominent in this area a number of years ago? Not surprising since both are now out of business. No doubt in my mind that customer service helped determine their fate.

Monday, February 27, 2012

Guardedly Optimistic

At last week’s breakfast meeting with all the department chairs and deans, I talked about the enrollment situation for this semester and this year. A substantial increase in the freshmen class, strong quality indicators, and some of the best retention numbers in our history make for a very positive picture. And a Presidential Debate on our campus next fall, further helps enhance the forecast for next year’s entering class. After finishing these comments, I moved on to discuss Moody’s higher education forecast of January 20, 2012. Moody’s is not always upbeat but their forecasts provide a well grounded assessment of what is and what is likely to be. In this forecast, Moody’s notes that for higher education, there will be greater political scrutiny, more sophisticated consumers and donors, increased price sensitivity on the part of consumers, increasing need for institutions to differentiate themselves, and also an increased need to become more efficient. Moody’s notes the “ongoing bifurcation” of higher education with very strong undergraduate demand occurring at the lowest cost, most affordable, extreme and at the highest prestige, highest quality, extreme. They also point out that there is a notable softening in demand for graduate education. We are all aware of the lack of job opportunities in much of teacher education but there is also a softening of demand for legal education and for graduate business education. Add to this the growth of online education and the weakness of the less selective sector of private higher education plus the fact that increased tuition discounting is not sustainable and you have key points in the picture that Moody’s sees and is reporting on. What does it all mean? Is the glass half or more than half empty? Or with a reviving economy, is the picture more positive than it appears. The answer is yes. We have our challenges but we have an opportunity. As an industry, many of us work very hard to differentiate our products. Many of us work very hard to provide a quality education. Many of us are very sophisticated at recruiting, and we also strive to limit tuition increases to the smallest possible increase. On the other hand, tuition discounting is still becoming more pervasive. It may be unsustainable in the long run but in the short run many of us have no choice but to compete. The increasing consumer focus on the tuition rate in the competition between much of private higher education and much of public higher education especially challenges the private sector going forward. And online education clearly challenges all of us by bringing much more competition just a click away. My generation and others in close proximity in age can be sure that higher education as we know it will continue throughout our professional lives. For future generations of administrators and faculty, the challenges, however, are great. If those of us in influential administrative positions try to coast, much of higher education as we know it will be placed at risk. If we continue to differentiate and make changes that reflect changing times, if we continue to respect core values, if we limit tuition increases and maximize efficiencies, if we can operate in an increasingly online environment, we should be OK. My choice is to not be complacent; if you do the same, we can all be guardedly optimistic.

Monday, March 7, 2011

Target Practice

I think we would all agree that our country is confronting a series of challenges in key areas such as the economy, health care, education, the environment, and national security.  How we handle these challenges will determine whether the United States continues its global leadership role or whether we are eclipsed by other great powers on this globe.  Regardless of your priorities, as we look to secure our future, education has to be a key part of any solution.  But at this moment in time, education and especially schools of education are under attack.

The basis for the attack is that often in K-12 education, our students are not performing up to their potential and no one would argue with that assessment.  The blame for this lack of performance or lack of progress is placed on the shoulders of our teachers and further blamed on the education they have received.  The solutions suggest that a stint with Teach for America or an experience with a museum could provide the same or a greater level of expertise than pursuing a graduate degree in education. The threat is clear— if schools of education don’t change, students will be encouraged to go elsewhere to pursue their graduate education. 

I happen to think that Teach for America is a terrific program and I love visiting museums and always find them to be a valuable learning experience.  There is no question that such programs can enhance teaching techniques and content knowledge.  But what about pedagogy?  What about the learning process? What about a more in depth understanding of the students we are educating? What about the need for a strong liberal arts and sciences background?  No one argues about the need for significant hands on experience for teachers but hands on cannot substitute for the proper educational foundation. Where is there any concrete evidence that teacher education has caused a lack of student performance? 

Clearly student performance is impacted by teaching quality and I’m not sure that that the prevalent K-12 structure sufficiently recognizes merit and the quality of teaching.  Yearly increases, step increases, and lane changes are almost totally tied to quantity of teaching and quantity of credits taken rather than the impact of the teacher. We have an obligation on the K-12 level and in higher education to give merit a more prominent place in the educational equation.  But we also all have an obligation, and that includes our public officials, to recognize that school funding, the student’s family,  the economic status of that family, the educational attainment of the family members, and discrimination all have significantly impacted student learning.  And does anyone think that alternative paths to certification will remedy these issues?

I wholeheartedly support outcomes assessment and efforts to measure the learning that has taken place.  I wholeheartedly support a continuous review of teacher education programs to also assess their effectiveness.  We can do a better job in providing K-12 education and in providing teacher education.  Change is necessary but so is an understanding of all the issues.  Looking for a target, looking for a simple solution to complex issues, won’t solve our problems.  You need to see the issues clearly and completely before significant progress can be made.  As educators we have an obligation to help make that happen.

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

It All Revolves Around Economics

When I was in college, it took me a long time to decide what to major in.  I started thinking about Psychology; next considered Philosophy; and ultimately settled on Economics.  Actually there were a few more disciplines along the way that I considered.  When I encountered a terrific teacher, that swayed me toward a particular major and, not surprisingly, when the faculty member was the opposite, my reaction was also the opposite.  What finally convinced me, and it is still true today, is that I found my passion in economics, and I remain convinced that Economics is the key factor in many of the formidable problems that our country and our globe are continuously confronting.

As an economist and as a long time educator, I often dwell on the economic benefits of education, especially higher education, that accrue to the person being educated.  The data is compelling and clearly demonstrates that in terms of benefits to the person and benefits to society, education matters a great deal.  Not surprising to me at all, and I’m convinced we aren’t even capturing all the benefits that education provides to the person and to society.

But there is another economic benefit of education and higher education that we also need to acknowledge.  That benefit is the contribution that schools make to the local, state, and national economy.  For example, at the end of last week, New York’s Commission on Independent Colleges and Universities (CICU) released their annual calculation of the economic impact of New York’s independent higher education sector.  New York’s 100+ independent colleges and universities contributed $54.3 billion to NY State’s economy.  The CICU study also noted that NY’s private colleges and universities provided on-campus employment for 174,000 people.  For Long Island, where Hofstra is located, the overall private college impact is $2.8 billion with more than 22,600 jobs.  Hofstra alone provides over 2,700 of these jobs.  How known is it and how appreciated is it that private higher education is one of the engines that drives New York State’s and Long Island’s economy?

These numbers reflect only one important sector of education in one state.  Add to these numbers the national dollar  impact of k-12 public education as well as public higher education, and you start to approach the major magnitude of our education industry.  And remember, that we are a clean and relatively green industry so our impact on the environment is another plus.  And we are often a cultural center for the communities in which we are located, which is still another plus.  And I could go on and on.  And once again, how known is it and how appreciated is it that education is a key engine for our national economy?

The conclusion is clear.  The benefits of education, economic and otherwise, surround all levels of education and all facets of education.  In this holiday season, as in all the other times of the year, education is truly the gift that keeps giving. Happy Holidays.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Sober Times

Earlier this week a relatively junior administrator asked me if there was any advice I could give him regarding a career in higher education administration.  Wanting to resist  stating the obvious (find what you feel really passionate about and devote your time, attention, and energy to that area), I thought about the crucial advice given to me early in my career and two specific pieces of advice came immediately to mind.